Welcome to Roman Cafe
Nestled in North Tonawanda, NY, Roman Cafe brings a warm ambiance and a diverse menu that captivates the senses. With years of culinary dedication, they serve an array of delectable dishes, from mouthwatering Veal Cutlet Parmesan to unique specialty pizzas like their Stinger Pizza, which boasts a hearty blend of chicken, steak, and fresh veggies. Consistently praised for their attentive service, many diners return for favorites like the French onion soup and wing specials. Despite mixed reviews on some items recently, the cafe's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction shines through. Each visit feels like a celebration of good food and community.
Roman Cafe: Reviews & Ratings
Our service was hands down a great experience. Amanda H was our server. She is the best! Haven't had Roman in awhile figured we stop in and have a family meal. The food was top notch . We will absolutely be back. I grabbed a menu on the way out so now we know all the amazing food we will have to try for our next visit! Thank you again Amanda H!!
Always consistent. Absolutely love the french onion soup & 5 wing lunch special!
April 2025 - I wanted to update this review. After taking a break from Roman Cafe for a while we started ordering for takeout again. After about 15 visits I can say we have had wonderful service and great food. I'm changing my review to 5 stars to reflect this. ------------------------------------------------------------------------- We started to frequent Roman Cafe when restaurants just started reopening after covid and their patio was open. We enjoyed the food and returned many times to dine inside. The last 2 years we mainly have ordered for takeout. The past couple months we have been enjoying the food less and less. The pizza isn't good like it used to be. When requesting extra crispy wings they are not cooked well let alone extra crispy. One of our guests ordered the lasagna and said it was dry and he couldn't finish it. The spaghetti has come out watery and more like a soup than a pasta dish, although the sauce does taste very good. And unfortunately the chicken fingers are basic store bought frozen ones. There are several restaurants in the area that make house made fingers, they turn out 100% better for minimal extra work. The curly fries do seem to be house made, and with 5 minutes in the air fryer at home they get less soggy are really pretty good. Our biggest complaint is when the gentleman answers the phone, we feel as if we are bothering him that we called to order. If the same gentleman is at the counter when we come in to pick up, we receive the same poor attitude from him in person. The Roman Cafe menu has been moved further back in our takeout menu folder. Perhaps we will try again after a while and see if things improve more like they used to be.
Consistently excellent, been patronizing Roman Cafe for decades. Just tried the handmade pizza rolls, and they are hearty and delicious. Everything is of the highest quality.
We order from Roman Cafe at least once a week. The food is always great! There was a bit of a mixup with what I ordered. They went above and beyond to rectify the issue! This is why we will always come back here whether doing take out or dine in. Thank you Roman Cafe for your excellent customer service and food!!
If there were 10 Stars available - they would received a "10" from our group of 3. We had a girls night out for supper and we were Blown Away with the service, food, and cocktails! I would ask the restaurant to maybe play some Frank Sinatra/Tony Bennett music for the ultimate Italian Experience. My new Favorite Place for a gathering!
Service and food very good. However counter staff can be more interested in thier cell phones than the customer.
This is a place has had consistently good food for as long as Ican remember. My entire family has been ordering from here for years, to the point where they know our order (I love their Monday hearty portion of spaghetti & a meatball with a side salad and my Brother in law loves their Friday fishfry) and just say see you soon instead of asking for our names or saying how long it will take to be ready (ALMOST EVERYTHING takes 20 minutes). Their salads are huge and they have great Greek and Italian dressings. Roman is also one of our go-to places to eat when family and friends are in town. Really can't go wrong with anything on their menu.
Location
-
797 Payne Ave, North Tonawanda, NY 14120, United States Hotline: +1 716-692-7048
Welcome to the Roman Cafe, located at 797 Payne Ave, North Tonawanda, NY 14120. This dining gem has captivated both locals and visitors with its exquisite selection of hearty Italian dishes and warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re in the mood for gourmet pastas, succulent seafood, or indulgent comfort food, Roman Cafe presents a menu steeped in flavor and tradition.
What sets Roman Cafe apart is its commitment to consistently excellent cuisine. With offerings like Cheese Ravioli, Lasagna, and the house-special Baked Lasagna, each dish is a testament to the culinary craftsmanship that defines this establishment. Reviews highlight the Fettucini Alfredo and Chicken Parmesan as true crowd-pleasers, while the Pasta Primavera offers a fresh take with sautéed vegetables drizzled in garlic oil, making it a delightful option for those seeking a lighter fare.
The seafood selections deserve special mention. The Shrimp Scampi, served in a creamy white sauce with vibrant green peppers and tomatoes, promises a flavor explosion atop a bed of linguini. For those with a penchant for bold spices, the Shrimp Louisiana presents a sweet and spicy experience that is hard to resist.
Customer experiences replete with praise underscore the cafe’s inviting service, particularly noting attentive staff like Amanda H., celebrated for creating an enjoyable dining experience. Consistent quality is echoed in the reviews, with patrons regularly ordering one of the top favorites, the French onion soup, or indulging in their well-loved wing lunch special.
Nonetheless, not all reviews are glowingly positive. A few customers have expressed concerns over the fluctuating quality of dishes, particularly with pizza and wings. However, they remain hopeful that with continued patronage, Roman Cafe will return to the stellar tastes and presentations they have come to cherish over the years.
In summary, Roman Cafe not only serves delightful meals but also creates memorable moments through its warm ambiance and knowledgeable staff. If you find yourself in North Tonawanda, allow yourself a culinary journey through Italy right at Roman Cafe, where every bite is crafted with care, and every visit feels like coming home.